I don’t ask for much … but I would appreciate SO MUCH if you could forward this to every person you know. Plaster it on your page, PLEASE … get the word out, and bring these killers to justice. Not for me, but for a grieving family that’s waited almost two years for closure on this horrific tragedy. Do it for Nichole’s two babies, that their mother’s killers won’t walk free.
Nichole Alloway disappeared on June 6, 2009, when she was 20 years old. A lot of you probably saw the news that summer of a young woman from North Carolina who went to Ohio to meet up with someone she met on MySpace … and was never heard from again.
My friend, who lived in Washington in 2009 but owns property in the McDermott, Ohio, area was looking at her hometown’s local news on the internet. She was shocked to see her address in the first story she read, and that a dead body was involved.
Who wouldn’t be shocked? She called the people who were house sitting for her and they told her the whole story. Somehow, Nichole had met a friend of the house sitters, she had been out to the house with her new-found Ohio friend, Nichole and her new beau went for a ride in his pickup, Nichole overdosed and died, and his methed-out, panicked brain told him to burn her body then dump her in the creek at the bottom of the hill.
Only … that story isn’t true. On Christmas Eve, 2010, someone told my friend the real story. The story of how their daughter helped the house sitters to trade all the pet food on the property for meth, then torture and mutilate a LOT of cats by (as an example and not encompassing all the filth and degradation) cutting out their tongues while they were still alive.
Oh! And she had also come down to my friend’s house and discovered the body in the barn, and helped the real killers to mutilate and dispose of the body … in exchange for meth. Oh! And maybe Nichole wasn’t really dead when she found her … and also maybe … she wasn’t dead when they started mutilating her.
So my friend and I began to wonder … after they found the body, why didn’t the police come out to the house? They knew the body had at least been mutilated on the property … wouldn’t they want to collect evidence of that crime? In fact, why did they not divulge that two of the first suspects lived at my friend’s house at the time of the murder? Why did the police not give the private investigator, hired by Nichole’s family, access to crucial files? How could they not see the orgy of evidence on my friend’s property? WHY … when contacted by America’s Most Wanted, did they turn down that assistance? Why was this not treated as a murder the moment the coroner came back with results showing NO drugs whatsoever in Nichole’s system? And WHY … why oh why … do they not question the two ladies they now have in custody in state prison and county jail?
Maybe it’s because this is a small community. Maybe it’s because the lead detective on the case – Detective Matt Spencer – is close personal friends, from childhood, with the male suspect? Or maybe it’s because they are just flat-out corrupt.
Everyone is suspicious of the local police. Nichole’s family, my friend, and me. No one trusts them, some people are afraid of them.
Then … yesterday, Detective Spencer unexpectedly shows up at my friend’s house. Not only does he have no business out there, he was told by the Scioto County Sheriff, Marty Donini, that my friend’s property is strictly off-limits, and that he shouldn’t have been working the case.
So why am I writing this to you, my Friends? I need your help in getting this information out there. We have contacted, so far:
The Family (who have our same limitations, and we so desperately want to help them)
US Marshall (who told us they couldn’t help)
FBI (who told us this is “not a Federal Matter,” even though the suspects most likely kidnapped Nichole and were manufacturing meth on the property)
Ohio State Attorney General (who has an answering machine and may not be a real person)
Scioto County Sheriff (who has done NOTHING)
In act, the "Powers that Be" have so far done NOTHING to solve Nichole's murder. If you want to do even more, you can contact the following and tell them that Nichole’s death will not go unnoticed … we will NOT forget about her!!
Scioto County Sheriff:
Marty V. Donini, Sheriff
Scioto County Sheriff's Office
1025 Sixteenth Street
Portsmouth, Ohio 45662
Dispatch: 740-354-7566
Corrections/Jail: 740-355-8277
Investigations: 740-355-8245
Civil Division: 740-355-8269
Fax: 740-355-8237
E-Mail: scso@sciotocountysheriff.com
FBI Field Office (Cincinnati):
John Weld Peck Federal Bldg.
550 Main Street, Suite 9000
Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 421-4310
Fax: (513) 562-5650
E-mail: Cincinnati@ic.fbi.gov
Ohio US Marshall:
Southern District of Ohio (S/OH)
U.S. Marshal: Cathy Jones
U.S. Courthouse
85 Marconi Boulevard, Room 460
Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 469-5540
Ohio State Attorney General Office: Special Prosecutions (614) 644-0729
Detective Matt Spencer: 740-354-7566
